preppymealBetaPlan my week
Back to recipes
Something sweet

My Best Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe

Serves 15 $0.67 est. / serving

A little inspiration for your kitchen, with a clear ingredient list and a cost estimate to help you plan.

Let’s cook
Estimated ingredient cost$10.06For the whole recipe · ingredients used
My Best Peanut Butter Cookie Recipe
Representative photograph; ingredients, garnishes and presentation may vary.
YOUR TIME IN THE KITCHEN

Make something good.

  1. 01

    Preheat over to 350 degrees. Sift flour and soda together and set aside.

  2. 02

    Blend sugars and shortening together in mixer. Add peanut butter. Mix well.

  3. 03

    Blend in eggs and vanilla. Add flour and soda. Mix well. Form into small balls and put on greased cookie sheet. Press each ball with a fork to make indentations in the dough. Bake approx.

  4. 04

    10 minutes. My kids loved them!

PreppyMeal adaptation with estimated quantities; original recipe credited below.

Ingredient quantities, working servings and costs may include PreppyMeal estimates. Totals cover required listed ingredients; optional extras and serving suggestions are excluded. Actual store prices and package costs vary.

Check the ingredients for your dietary needs. Nutrition and allergen-free claims are not verified for this collection.

Good food deserves credit.

Recipe source

Foodista / Common Pile

Original recipe · CC BY 3.0

PreppyMeal formatting, ingredient normalization and labeled quantity/cost estimates. Original source credited.

Photograph

Photo of Salty Spicy Peanut Butter Cookies — Foodista. Source-provided contributor credit: By Foodista member Jaime Caldwell

Original photo · CC BY 2.0

sRGB conversion, square cropping, metadata removal, WebP resizing; no image generation
Ingredient photographs (5)

  • Sugar, dried

    File:Bowl of white sugar.jpg — Douglas P Perkins. Own work

    Original photo · CC BY 3.0

    Foreground cutout, sRGB conversion, cropping, metadata removal, WebP resizing; no image generation

  • Egg

    Own work

    Original photo · Public domain

    Foreground cutout, sRGB conversion, cropping, metadata removal, WebP resizing; no image generation

  • Vanilla extract

    File:Homemade Vanilla Extract (4107750384).jpg — Veganbaking.net from USA. Homemade Vanilla Extract

    Original photo · CC BY-SA 2.0

    Foreground cutout, sRGB conversion, cropping, metadata removal, WebP resizing; no image generation; Adapted image licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0; original and modifications share this license.

  • White flour

    File:All-Purpose Flour (4107895947).jpg — Veganbaking.net from USA. All-Purpose Flour

    Original photo · CC BY-SA 2.0

    Foreground cutout, sRGB conversion, cropping, metadata removal, WebP resizing; no image generation; Adapted image licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0; original and modifications share this license.

  • Baking soda, dried

    File:No name sans nom baking soda.jpg — Michael Francis McCarthy. https://www.flickr.com/photos/sagamiono/4299196396/

    Original photo · CC BY 2.0

    Foreground cutout, sRGB conversion, cropping, metadata removal, WebP resizing; no image generation